On average, care providers spend more than 52 minutes of their working day on quality registrations. Most of this is for accountability purposes and is in addition to keeping track of the patient's situation. A joint study by the Radboudumc, Rijnstate and UMCG investigated that only 36% of these registrations can be used to improve care and that the registration burden weighs on the motivation of care providers.
Registering pain when the patient is not in pain
During the study, which has now been published in the International Journal of Health Policy and Management, healthcare providers indicated which registrations they felt were unnecessary. Nurses and physicians find it annoying when, while standing at a patient's bedside, they only look at a screen on which things need to be registered. As a result, they look at the patient much less, which is not pleasant for both patient and care worker.
Another remark that came back a lot, is that it is necessary to measure what does not feel logical. For example, registering a pain score, while there is no pain. Or the recording of bedsores in someone who comes for day treatment, or the measurement of malnutrition in young, healthy people who are admitted for a simple treatment like an almond operation. Some caregivers indicated that this way they no longer learn to trust their feelings, but only the scores.
Caregivers need to register more than 90 records
In the more than 52 minutes that care providers spend on quality registrations, they keep an average of 91 quality indicators per department. This includes 1380 variables. As many as 24 parties request these registrations, ranging from accreditation agencies to government and health insurers. There is a 47% overlap between the requests, but the way in which they are entered and maintained is not uniform, which means that a great deal of time is lost. In total, 57% is registered mainly for accountability purposes, 18% for internal control and 25% with quality improvement as the main goal.
But one third of the registrations feel useful
Only 36% were perceived by care providers as useful for improving the quality of daily care. Results of the survey show that some registrations even result in less job satisfaction and motivation. Principal researcher Marieke Zegers of the Radboudumc: "It is high time care providers and policymakers sat down together to coordinate their information needs. The amount and inefficiencies frustrate care providers."
Research as part of the Experiment Meaningful Registration (ZIRE)
In the Radboudumc, the Intensive Care department participated in the research. Instead of 102 indicators, only sixteen indicators are registered here. "We have been given room by the Health Care Inspectorate (IGJ) to temporarily let go of the quality indicators and, together with doctors, nurses and ex-IC patients, to determine which registrations are really needed. If you limit yourself to this 'core set', you can maintain or even improve the quality of care. Because time that you no longer spend on registration can go towards actually improving the quality of care," says Marieke Zegers.
The research carried out by the three hospitals (Radboudumc in Nijmegen, UMCG in Groningen and Rijnstate in Arnhem) is part of ZIRE (Zinvolle Registratie), in which experiments are being conducted to reduce the number of registrations. The experiment is carried out under the auspices of the NFU consortium Quality of Care and Care Institute Netherlands. The report with results and recommendations will be published in the autumn.
Marieke Zegers, Gepke L. Veenstra, Gerard Gerritsen, Rutger Verhage, Hans J.G. van der Hoeven, Gera A. Welker.
Related news items
How healthy is James Bond? - A flu to a kill No time to die: the pathogens surrounding secret agent 00721 October 2021
James Bond made a total of 25 films between 1962 and 2021. In all those films, secret agent 007 washed his hands only twice, even though he often stayed in not so hygienic places with considerable health risks. Radboudumc researchers examined all the health risks in the 47 countries Bond visited.read more
Surprisingly dominant cause underlying type I congenital defect of glycosylation21 October 2021
Alex Garanto, Melissa Bärenfänger, Mirian Janssen, and Dirk Lefeber published a new study, identifying a surprisingly dominant genetic cause underlying type I congenital defect of glycosylation with neuromusculoskeletal phenotypes.read more
Sensitive blood-test as a patient-friendly alternative for bone marrow-based cancer monitoring20 October 2021
Hans Jacobs and Pieter Langerhorst, theme Cancer development and immune defense, and colleagues are one step closer to implementation of personalized diagnostics for bone marrow-based cancer monitoring.read more
Register for peer coaching for RIMLS PhD candidates20 October 2021
As a PhD candidate, you are in the lead of your own learning process, but you don’t need to do this alone. Register for the peer-coaching group ‘Stay in the lead – Together’ before 11 November 2021.read more